Millennial problems

September 6 2019 by Nick Ferguson

A brave insurance executive was confronted with some tough questions recently when he faced a crowd of millennial marketing folk at a conference in Singapore.

The discussion, which took place at the Mumbrella Asia Finance Marketing Summit last week, highlighted some of the problems that life insurers face as they strive to transform their agent-led businesses into millennial-friendly digital operations that are fit for purpose in the 2020s and beyond.

Prudential’s head of customer experience and segments for Singapore, Harish Agarwal, was told by one participant in the question-and-answer session that most people don’t want to buy his product and don’t like his product.

“You are right: nobody wakes up wanting to buy insurance,” he said, unfazed by what obviously seemed like a challenging proposition to a roomful of marketers. “But the fact that you need it does not go away.”

It is true that insurance has long been a product that is sold rather than bought. Prudential employs 5,000 agents in Singapore who spend their days trying to convince people that they need it, but a problem for many life insurers is that young people today are increasingly resistant to the message.

“Insurance does not give you instant gratification and we hear that’s why it does not appeal to millennials,” Agarwal said, admitting that the industry has a poor reputation among young consumers who expect high standards of customer service and transparency. “Not liking our product is because we have traditionally made it so complicated. You can’t buy a savings product and completely understand what you buy.”

And it’s not just the message that’s the problem. Young people are also resistant to the messenger. Even Agarwal himself admitted, jokingly, that millennials “detest talking to us”.

Customers who have grown up online expect products that are simpler and more flexible — much more flexible. They want to shape products how they want and for how long.

“If we are able to do that, will have overcome your dislike and reluctance to talk to us,” said Agarwal.

One challenge is that this invariably means selling online, which agents generally don’t like. Prudential and most other life insurers have faced uproar from agents about the sale of top products online, correctly perceiving digital platforms as a competitive threat.

But the millennials throwing questions at Agarwal were also highly sceptical of companies that want their data, with one citing the Netflix documentary The Great Hack, which focuses on the abuse of Facebook data by Cambridge Analytica during the 2016 US presidential campaign.

“I am not comfortable with this constant conversation about it being a ‘challenge’ that you can’t access and use more of my data,” said the audience member.

Such concerns are an increasing problem amid the rampant abuse and misuse of personal data by corporations. By now, most people on the planet have probably had at least some of their data stolen thanks to lax security by a company they previously trusted — and this erosion of trust makes it ever more difficult to sell online products that require the exchange of highly sensitive information.

Further, audience members were worried about the effect that sharing data through apps — such as how often they work out — might have on their premiums.

“There’s a lot of scepticism that when you share data you will get penalised for not having the right lifestyle,” admitted Agarwal. “But when you buy insurance, you have to declare your pre-existing conditions. And if you lie at that time, the claim does not get paid out. If you start sharing data, it is no different.”

Clearly, convincing millennials to buy life insurance is a tough proposition, yet with life expectancy in Singapore heading towards 100 and retirements routinely lasting 30-plus years, they may need it more than they realise.

MORE FROM: Insights
  • Lessons from Jebi

    • September 20

    Losses from Typhoon Jebi should not have been such a big surprise, but Faxai will test if the lessons have been learned.

  • Protection products drive value

    • September 20

    Search for growth in current low-yield environment forces shift from traditional life insurance products.

  • China’s slowing growth

    • September 13

    Continued economic growth has never looked more challenging, and that inevitably weighs on the outlook for insurers.

  • Mining in survival mode

    • September 13

    The mining insurance market is hardening after huge losses, insurer retrenchment and environmental concerns.